What is one unique or unconventional advertising tactic you tried that proved surprisingly effective for your small business? What made it stand out?

Question

In a market saturated with traditional advertising, small businesses must innovate to stand out. This article delves into unconventional advertising tactics that have proven effective, with insights from industry experts. Learn from those who've mastered the art of grabbing attention without breaking the bank.

Georgi Petrov · Answer

One unconventional advertising tactic that proved surprisingly effective for our small business was creating a personalized direct mail campaign that leveraged data from our CRM and customer interactions. 
We were running a digital marketing agency at the time, and although we relied heavily on online ads and email marketing, we noticed that our audience wasn't engaging as much as we hoped. So, we decided to take a more personalized, offline approach—a tactic that's not commonly used in the digital space, especially for service-based businesses.
We analyzed our client data to identify high-value leads—those who had shown interest in our services but had yet to convert. Instead of sending generic marketing materials, we designed custom postcards and packages that included insights relevant to each prospect's business. 
For instance, we included a personalized message about how we could help solve a specific pain point they were facing, based on the data we had gathered from their website or social media presence.
What made this tactic stand out was the personal touch. In a world where digital ads and emails are often ignored or dismissed, receiving something tangible that speaks directly to their business challenges made a lasting impression on our prospects. It felt more like a one-on-one conversation than a cold sales pitch, and as a result, we saw a notable increase in responses.
The campaign led to a 30% increase in client conversions within two months, and we found that the personalized nature of the direct mail created a stronger emotional connection with our prospects, making them more likely to trust us with their business. What surprised us most was that something as traditional as direct mail could stand out in a digital-heavy landscape and deliver such high returns.
This experience reinforced the power of personalization and reminded me that sometimes, blending old-school techniques with modern data insights can create a unique, highly effective marketing strategy.

Sally Johnson · Answer

As CEO, I've learned that sometimes the most effective advertising tactics are the ones that catch people off guard. One unconventional approach that worked surprisingly well for us was what I like to call our "Silent Disco Invasion."
We partnered with a local park to set up a surprise silent disco event on a busy Saturday afternoon. We handed out wireless headphones to unsuspecting park-goers, each tuned to different channels playing various genres of music from bands we represent. Imagine the scene: suddenly, you see people of all ages dancing to music only they can hear, creating this surreal, joyful atmosphere in the middle of a regular day at the park.
Sometimes the best way to make noise is to be silent. Our silent disco showed people the power of music to bring joy, even when you can't hear it.
What made this tactic stand out was its ability to create a shared experience that was both personal and communal. Passersby were intrigued by the seemingly spontaneous dance party, and many joined in out of sheer curiosity. We had team members on hand to explain what was happening and share information about our booking services.
The event generated a buzz far beyond what we anticipated. People started sharing videos and photos on social media, and local news outlets picked up the story. It wasn't just about advertising our services; it was about creating a memorable moment that people associated with our brand.
This experience taught me that effective advertising doesn't always have to be loud or in-your-face. Sometimes, it's about creating an experience that people want to be part of and share with others. It also showed me the power of bringing music into unexpected places—which is, after all, what we do.
The success of this campaign wasn't just in the immediate buzz it created, but in the lasting impact. We saw an increase in inquiries for months afterward, with many clients specifically mentioning the silent disco event. It proved to me that when you can tap into people's emotions and create a positive, shared experience, you're doing more than advertising—you're building a community around your brand.

Yoyao Hsueh · Answer

Instead of chasing viral moments, we turned our client success stories into detailed topical authority case studies. The unconventional part? We focused on publishing their failures alongside their wins—complete with real data showing their ranking setbacks before breakthrough moments.
This raw transparency resonated deeply with our target audience of seasoned marketers. Website engagement jumped 156% as readers spent an average of 12 minutes studying these unvarnished journeys. The ads didn't just attract attention; they built trust through brutal honesty.
For businesses seeking to stand out, consider sharing the struggles behind your successes. Authenticity, backed by real data, will always outperform polished perfection in building lasting customer relationships.

Matthew Goulart · Answer

An unconventional tactic that worked exceptionally well for our digital marketing agency was offering free, interactive website audits during live webinars. In my experience, clients often know their website needs improvement but feel overwhelmed by technical jargon and uncertain about where to start. We hosted webinars where participants submitted their websites in advance, and during the session, we conducted live audits, highlighting quick fixes and long-term strategies to boost traffic and conversions. After just one webinar, five attendees became paying clients, generating over $15,000 in new business. I believe this method stood out because it gave immediate, actionable value in real time, while showcasing our expertise in a transparent and engaging way.

Anders Bill · Answer

One unconventional advertising tactic we implemented was creating co-branded landing pages for individual ambassadors and influencers. In my experience, giving partners a personalized space tailored to their audience created a stronger sense of authenticity and trust. For example, an influencer we worked with had a landing page featuring their photo, a message in their voice, and a curated selection of products they loved. This approach increased their audience's engagement by 40% compared to generic campaign pages. I believe it stood out because it felt like a seamless extension of their personal brand, making their followers more likely to convert.
For me personally, what made this tactic so effective was the way it fostered deeper connections between brands and their partners. By allowing influencers to showcase their individuality while promoting products, we saw higher-quality leads and a 25% increase in referral sales. It also helped partners feel more invested in the campaigns, which led to more enthusiastic promotions. I think this personalized strategy elevated the word-of-mouth experience and created a win-win scenario for both merchants and their partners.

Inge Von Aulock · Answer

One unconventional advertising tactic we tried was running a "reverse ad campaign" where we showcased common frustrations with our competitors rather than directly promoting our product. We created a series of short, humorous videos highlighting pain points like confusing interfaces or poor customer support, ending with the tagline: "There's a better way. Meet Penfriend," or "Write with Penfriend."
What made it stand out was the relatability—it resonated deeply with our audience because it felt like we understood their struggles. The humor and honesty also sparked conversations and shares, driving organic reach far beyond what we expected. This approach worked because it flipped the traditional advertising script, focusing on empathy first, which built trust and curiosity about our solution. It proved that even a small business can stand out with creativity and a clear understanding of customer pain points.

Dan Brown · Answer

A few years ago, my company worked with a local street artist to create a mural on a downtown building. It featured our brand's message. It was unconventional, as we're a digital-focused business, but it grabbed attention and led to more social media chatter. When we displayed the mural, we noticed a large increase in organic traffic and referrals. My recommendation is to try working with local talent to maximize the impact of your marketing. Create campaigns that get people to notice your brand so you can attract new leads from business owners who would otherwise overlook your company.

John Butterworth · Answer

Getting potential customers to share their contact details is no easy task. We knew we had to offer something truly valuable to earn their trust, so we created a campaign that not only solved a pressing problem but also showcased our expertise as an SEO agency.
Our idea was to use AI platform ChatGPT to create a custom GPT that could provide personalized and practical advice to improve your keyword rankings. The GPT we built was fully trained on Google's guidelines and provided advice by first analyzing your website, and then your competitors' websites, to understand why the competing websites are performing better.
We promoted the tool through targeted social media posts, focusing on how it delivered free, personalized SEO advice to any website. To access the tool, prospects needed to click the link in our post, which took them to a squeeze page which asked for their email address, after entering our platform would send them the access link via autoresponder.
The response was fantastic, generating lots of quality leads from businesses and individuals who were actively trying to improve their website's SEO. In other words, prospects who would be easier for us to convert because they already understood the value of SEO services.
However, what truly made this campaign stand out for our agency was how cheap this campaign was to run. We can distribute the GPT at scale without it costing us a penny for people to access the tool and use it as often as they like.

Laurel Robbins · Answer

One unconventional tactic we tried was creating a Secret Santa Gift Finder and Gifts for Colleagues CustomGPT—an interactive AI tool designed to solve a seasonal dilemma: finding thoughtful gifts quickly and easily. This approach was unique because it wasn't a direct ad—it was a value-driven, shareable experience that subtly promoted our expertise in AI-powered marketing. 
What made it stand out was the combination of practicality and fun. The tool engaged users by solving a real problem while showcasing how AI can be creatively used to enhance the customer experience. It also highlighted our brand's capabilities in building innovative marketing solutions without feeling pushy or salesy. 
The results were surprising and highly effective. Users loved the tool, shared it with colleagues and friends, and in doing so, organically expanded our reach. It proved that advertising doesn't always have to feel like advertising—sometimes providing genuine value can be the most effective way to connect with your audience.

Samuel Huang · Answer

We launched an “instant controversy campaign” by placing Telegram ads that boldly challenged popular social media platforms like Facebook and Instagram, calling them overpriced and overrated for scaling businesses. This tactic was simple: provoke curiosity and spark debates by directly questioning competitors' value. The ads grabbed immediate attention, generated viral discussions, and drove a 35% spike in client inquiries within a month.
What made it stand out was its audacity and focus on our target audience—entrepreneurs seeking cost-effective marketing alternatives. It cut through the noise by addressing pain points head-on, making our solution memorable. By leveraging Telegram's niche yet engaged user base, we effectively positioned ourselves as the disruptive underdog, which resonated with startups and small businesses alike. This approach turned a small budget into massive organic reach and positioned us as thought leaders in the Telegram ad space.

Randy Kunik · Answer

One unconventional advertising tactic that proved surprisingly effective for me was organizing a community cleanup event. The idea was rooted in the belief that genuine connection with the community can create a lasting impression far beyond traditional advertising. By inviting volunteers to join in beautifying a local area, the event served not only as a way to make a tangible difference but also as an opportunity to foster relationships and trust within the community.
What made this strategy so impactful was its authenticity. Rather than focusing on promotional messaging or direct advertising, the event showcased a commitment to the values of community and collaboration. People weren't just hearing about these values, they were experiencing them alongside me and others who share a desire to contribute positively to our surroundings.
This approach stood out because it went against the grain of conventional marketing. There was no hard sell, no flashy campaign, just action. Participants shared their involvement organically through word-of-mouth and social media, posting photos and tagging the event. This created a ripple effect, reaching people who may not have attended but appreciated the initiative. Additionally, the cleanup caught the attention of local media, further amplifying the message without additional effort.
The benefits went beyond visibility or publicity. By actively engaging with others in a hands-on effort, I demonstrated a genuine investment in the well-being of the community, something that resonates deeply with people. It fostered trust and created a sense of goodwill that is hard to achieve through traditional means.
Reflecting on this experience, it reinforced the importance of stepping out of the typical advertising mold. Sometimes, the most effective way to promote what you stand for is to show it in action. The connections built during that event have had a lasting impact, and it's a tactic I'd recommend to anyone looking for an authentic way to make a difference while strengthening their presence in the community.

Alari Aho · Answer

We ran an experiment offering free Toggle premium subscriptions to bootstrapped startups. The campaign sparked conversations among founders, driving unexpected word-of-mouth marketing. It wasn't about revenue but building relationships with future business leaders. Many of those startups grew and became our loyal customers later. Supporting their success aligned perfectly with our company philosophy. 
The startup subscription campaign stood out because it wasn't a hard sell. It showed genuine support for underdogs trying to build their dreams. By prioritizing relationships over profit, we created trust and emotional loyalty. People remembered us for empowering them when they needed it most. Authentic generosity turned into lasting goodwill for the brand.

Joel Butterly · Answer

Launching a monthly podcast turned out to be one of the most unconventional yet surprisingly effective strategies I've ever tried. The goal wasn't to sell anything directly but to create a space for meaningful conversations around personal growth and community stories. I wanted to provide real value, not just noise, and in doing so, it naturally drew people in without feeling like a traditional ad.
The podcast format allowed for a deep exploration of topics that resonated with listeners: resilience, education, leadership, and the pursuit of passions. Each episode featured guests with unique perspectives, sharing insights from their own journeys. These weren't just polished success stories; they were authentic accounts of challenges, growth, and transformation. That authenticity was key; it created a genuine connection with the audience.
What made this approach so effective was how it built trust over time. People tuned in because they found the content relatable and actionable. They didn't feel like they were being sold to; they felt like they were part of a conversation that mattered. As listeners engaged more, they began sharing episodes with friends, family, and colleagues, creating an organic ripple effect that amplified the reach far beyond what I anticipated.
The most rewarding part of the experience was seeing the podcast evolve into more than just a strategy. It became a platform for inspiration and dialogue, aligning with my philosophy that the foundation for success lies in identifying and nurturing core strengths and passions. This effort reinforced the idea that real connection, grounded in shared values and meaningful content, is far more powerful than any traditional advertisement.

Divy Patel · Answer

We found that partnering with local schools and organizing interactive workshops on creating shaved snow desserts was surprisingly effective. It wasn't just about giving out samples; it was about teaching kids and parents the art and science behind our desserts, creating an engaging experience. This approach not only increased foot traffic by 30% but also fostered a sense of community around our brand.
Additionally, we introduced a monthly "Flavor Inventor" challenge, inviting customers to submit their own shaved snow flavor ideas. The winning flavors would be featured on our menu, which encouraged customer participation and brand loyalty. This unconventional advertising strategy not only broadened our flavor offerings but also led to a 25% increase in repeat customer visits. By involving our community directly in our offerings, we created a deeper connection that traditional marketing methods couldn't achieve.

David E. Preszler · Answer

Our law firm tried something unconventional by hosting a “Legal Myth-Busting” AMA (Ask Me Anything) on social media. We addressed questions like, “Can you sue for emotional distress?” and “What does 'pain and suffering' mean in legal terms?” It demystified legal jargon and positioned us as approachable experts. The event went viral locally, increasing consultations by 35% in the following month. It stood out because it wasn't about pushing services but about educating and empowering people, which naturally built trust in our brand.

Ben Guttmann · Answer

When I ran my first agency, we helped launch a very popular book in the gluten-free space, and we wanted to leverage that success into more publishing projects. Emails and ads weren't breaking through, so we decided to do something people couldn't miss: we bought bagels, wrapped them in caution tape, and sealed them in an acrylic box with a note about how we helped raise the alarm about carbs. We mailed these boxes to publishers, agents, and authors around the country, and soon, our phones were ringing off the hook. The lesson was to zig when everybody else zags—be so different and creative that people can't ignore you.

Unconventional Advertising: 16 Tactics that Work for Small Businesses

Unconventional Advertising: 16 Tactics that Work for Small Businesses

Create Personalized Direct Mail Campaigns

Host Surprise Silent Disco Events

Share Honest Client Success Stories

Offer Free Live Website Audits

Develop Co-Branded Influencer Landing Pages

Run Reverse Ad Campaigns

Collaborate with Local Street Artists

Create Custom AI Tools for SEO

Launch Seasonal Interactive AI Tools

Challenge Competitors with Bold Ads

Organize Community Cleanup Events

Offer Free Premium Subscriptions to Startups

Start a Monthly Podcast

Host Interactive Dessert Workshops

Conduct Legal Myth-Busting AMAs

Send Creative Promotional Packages

Submit Your Answer

Join our email list to receive the latest events, news, and updates from AMA Phoenix.